Text of Ninth Circuit ruling (click here)
August 8, 2008
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Oliver Bernstein, Sierra Club, 512-477-2152
Robert Tohe, Sierra Club, 928-606-9420
Howard Shanker, 1-877-848-9300
Tribes, Environmental Organizations to Continue Effort to Protect Vulnerable Population, Sacred Mountain from Ski Resort Development and Pollution
FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. –Arizona’s sacred San Francisco Peaks and the neighboring tribal communities were denied environmental justice today in a split decision by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, ruling in favor of the Arizona Snowbowl ski resort in its efforts to expand and contaminate the area.
“The court failed to consider the claims of the impacts to human health form coming into contact with the treated waste from reclaimed water and did not take seriously the tribes’ legal claims because of a court technicality,” said Andy Bessler with the Sierra Club in Flagstaff, Arizona. “The decision leaves unaddressed water quality issues, since the Court failed to decide if using reclaimed water on the Peaks was safe for the environment or for human health.”
The San Francisco Peaks, north of Flagstaff, Arizona, are sacred to 13 tribes and are important spiritual and geographic boundaries. The tribes had brought legal claims under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) and the National Environmental Policy Act against the U.S. Forest Service from implementing a snowmaking proposal using reclaimed water to make artificial snow on the Peaks.
Attorney Howard Shanker represented the tribes and the Sierra Club, and he said, “The opinion is unfortunate and, in my opinion wrong. The Court places itself in the position of judging the legitimacy of Native American beliefs and practices. It becomes the arbiter of religion which is not the proper role for the courts. The evidence clearly shows that the Peaks are important to 13 of the Tribes in the southwestern United States and that using sewer water to make snow on them constitutes a significant burden on the Tribe’s ability to practice their religion.”
The Sierra Club agrees with the minority’s dissention, which read, “In so holding, the majority misstates the evidence below, misstates the law under RFRA and misunderstands the very nature of religion.” (from page 39 of decision). The Sierra Club will consult with co-plaintiffs to determine next steps following this misinformed ruling.
“The Sierra Club will continue to support our tribal partners to bring as much protection to the Peaks as possible and will continue to educate the public about the importance of protecting sacred lands located on public lands, from irresponsible developments like artificial snowmaking,” said Sierra Club Environmental Justice organizer Robert Tohe.
More on next page
The preliminary March ruling was one of the most important in recent years under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. In addition to finding that the snowmaking plan would have desecrated this sacred area, the court decided that the U.S. Forest Service failed to fully disclose the risks posed by human ingestion of artificial snow.
Tribes involved in the lawsuit include Navajo, Yavapai-Apache, White Mountain Apache, Hopi, Havasupai, and Hualapai. Since the first major expansion of the “Snowbowl” ski areas occurred more than twenty-eight years ago, tribes have been involved in court battles over the San Francisco Peaks.
Breaking news articles ...
Appeals court gives green light to Snowbowl snowmaking
Bizjournals.com, NC - 2 hours agoThe Arizona Snowbowl can go ahead with plans to upgrade its operations, including making artificial snow, following release of a ruling Friday by the Ninth ...
Ninth Court sides with Snowbowl in San Francisco Peaks dispute
Arizona Daily Star, AZ - 5 hours agoBy Howard Fischer The operators of Snowbowl are entitled to use recycled sewage to make snow on the San Francisco Peaks despite objections of several Native ...
Snowmaking OK'd at Snowbowl resort
AZ Central.com, AZ - 5 hours agoby Michael Kiefer - Aug. 8, 2008 11:10 AM A federal court of appeals on Friday ruled that using reclaimed wastewater to make artificial snow at a Flagstaff ...
Appeals court says snowmaking OK on Ariz. Snowbowl
Tucson Citizen, AZ - 5 hours agoAP PHOENIX — A federal appeals court has approved snowmaking using reclaimed wastewater at the Arizona Snowbowl ski resort north of Flagstaff. ...
Photo: Longest Walk at San Francisco Peaks/Photo credit Save the Peaks