Indigenous Peoples and Human Rights

November 14, 2026

Medical Survey on Standing Rock Results in Ethics Concerns

Standing Rock photo by photographer Rob Wilson

Indigenous People concerned over ethics of medical survey at Standing Rock

By Brenda Norrell, Censored News, November 13, 2026, Updated Today

Indigenous People are concerned over the ethics of a medical survey of Lakota and others who were present at Standing Rock during the resistance to Dakota Access Pipeline.

Native people said reporter Sandy Tolan should cease and desist from continuing his medical survey for Rolling Stone magazine.

Tolan was warned not to proceed with the survey, after distributing the survey during a gathering at Standing Rock in October. Tolan, a non-Indian, is ignoring the warning and continues.

The medical survey's questions put Water Protectors safety and freedom at risk by asking them specifically which protests they were present at.

This includes the dog attack on Water Protectors, Blackwater Bridge action, and Treaty Camp stand.

There are currently cases before the courts in North Dakota and the Netherlands. There are also individual cases of critical injuries inflicted by law enforcement before the courts in the United States.

Tolan's survey asks sensitive questions about sexual ability and reproduction. Even though this part is optional, it is alarming. Tolan has placed the survey online.

Tolan is researching a connection between the ill health and deaths of Water Protectors, and possible toxic aerial spraying or chemical poisoning of Water Protectors ten years ago, in 2016 and 2017, at Standing Rock. 

Native people point out that free, prior and informed consent, as stated in the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, is required before proceeding with research.

Online communications are never totally secure. It is not possible to guarantee that the information will remain confidential.

Although Protonmail is being relied on, Protonmail in Switzerland actually turns over user information when compelled by Swiss law enforcement or treaty obligations.

All emails in the United States that are sent to countries outside the United States are monitored by federal agents and stored at the discretion of agents, in accordance with federal intelligence law.

Further, in regards to ethics in journalism, it is highly irregular for a news reporter to distribute a written survey for sensitive medical information to a vulnerable population, especially on tribal land and without the tribe's permission.

Besides being a news reporter, Tolan is a university professor and book author.

People question who wrote the survey, where the information will be stored, and if their medical information will be used for profit in books or be published as university research.

Native people said in comments online that they regret now giving their medical information in this survey. They say they were misled and believed attorneys initiated the survey.

Native people also question who the 'Water Protector' group is that he is working with. They also question the ethics of some individuals working with Tolan.

The group's link is shown on Tolan's public post. https://waterprotectorhealthinquiry.online/



The cases before the courts include Energy Transfer v Greenpeace. Now on appeal, Greenpeace denies it was responsible for the protest in 2016 and 2017.

The district Court in Morton County, North Dakota, awarded the pipeline $345 million. The local jury in the biased area, where oil workers live, believed that Greenpeace was responsible for the resistance.

It was in fact led by Lakota from the beginning in the spring of 2016.

On the international level, a Dutch court ruled it has jurisdiction following a case filed by Greenpeace against Energy Transfer. The case is proceeding.

Individual cases of critical injuries due to law enforcement's violence remain before the courts with the possibility of appeals.

In reference to the survey, in general, when a person states they were present at the scene of an alleged crime, they can be ordered to testify.

Regarding the lack of e-mail security at Protonmail, the web service turned over user information to Swiss law enforcement in a case in 2021.


Copyright Censored News.


No comments: