Indigenous Peoples and Human Rights

May 3, 2010

Debra White Plume: Military Helicopters at Wounded Knee? Traditional Lakota Elders Say 'NO WAY!'

Military Helicopters at Wounded Knee? Traditional Lakota Elders Say No Way!
By Debra White Plume. May 1. 2010
Censored News

Military helicopters approaching from the North could be seen by a crowd of 60 or so Lakota people, gathered at the base of the hill where victims of the 1890 Wounded Knee Massacre lay buried in a mass grave. As the three black helicopters passed overhead and started to turn around, “Block the helicopters!” could be heard faintly, drowned out by the sound of thumping chopper blades and the harsh wind, words shouted by a grandmother. The people began to run toward the helicopters, which were nearing the mass grave.

Young men reached the hilltop first, carrying staffs adorned with eagle feathers and colored ribbon. Dozens of young children ran in groups up the hill, holding hands, some were carrying sage. The elders brought up the rear, escorted by several young men. The first helicopter landed a few feet from the mass grave. The Lakota men ran up to it, holding their staffs, yelling at the military to leave Wounded Knee, the elders did not want them there. As the other two helicopters began to descend, four women ran to get under the choppers, waving red banners and a United Nations flag. The helicopters came lower, the women did not budge. They yelled at the soldiers hanging out of the helicopters, “Leave, you are not wanted at Wounded Knee.” The three black helicopters flew away.

“Military transport coming to Wounded Knee? Why, to intimidate us? I came here to talk about my family, but now I am thinking, I am 80 years old, I pray every day. The Chairlady said to come here and talk about our families, but for people to make money off of this place, they shouldn’t do that. This is a place to pray, the military have no place here” said Stanley Looking Elk, an elder and former Tribal President.

Marie Not Help Him loudly questioned the people present, “Why are you doing this? I invited them here! My great grandfather Dewey Beard survived this. I wanted to tell our story,” saying she belongs to the Wounded Knee Survivor’s Association. She asked the Tribal Police on site to arrest the people. The Tribal Police declined to make arrests, but did step in when Not Help Him ran up to elder Wilma Thin Elk, shoving her finger into Mrs. Thin Elk’s face, yelling. A young woman jumped in front of elder Thin Elk, and told Not Help Him to stop. Tribal Police intervened, escorting Not Help Him away from elder Thin Elk.

As the four carloads of Tribal Police attempted crowd control, yelling at people to disperse, Vic Camp stepped in front of the elders and women the police were trying to push back. “We are not here to argue against our own people, we are here to defend this killing ground from the military coming here. They don’t belong on this land. They were already here. Our ancestors are lying in the ground over there because the US military was already here. Our people have a right to be here,” Camp did not back away.

Olowan Martinez said, “The Tribe did not even tell us they were doing this, we found out last night, me and my children live right down the hill. The US military can go elsewhere to hear the story. Our ancestors at Wounded Knee were killed by the US military and my father, a Veteran of Wounded Knee 1973, lies buried there, they have no respect to come back to where they put the blood of our relatives on the ground.”

“This is sacred ground, not a tourist attraction, they flew in and out like tourists. They already know what happened here, there was no good communication about this,” said Alex White Plume, also an elder and former Tribal President, saying he supports the younger generation.

When the elders began speaking, several people asked Not Help Him to stay and listen, and to tell the people the story of her Grandfather, but she and her family got in their vehicles and left.

“Those choppers and the ones who planned this are disrespectful to our loved ones. Didn’t the few people who planned this know that this whole thing is so insensitive and wrong that the Lakota’s would come out to defend this ground? We want our children to grow up respectful. We have to teach them,” said Autumn Conroy Two Bulls, founder of Helping Every Lakota Person.

Wilma Thin Elk said, “When I was a little girl my Grandma, who was a survivor, used to bring us here and tell what happened. Those helicopters could have shot us, we stand here with no way to defend ourselves, I’m a descendant of Wounded Knee, too. Is that how our ancestors felt? When they saw the military with their guns, and they had no guns? Now they are all lying over there in that grave.”

Garfield Little Dog, Council Representative from Wounded Knee District said, “Several elders and survivors of the Wounded Knee Massacre expressed their dislike for the military to come here. It made them feel bad, some are facing serious illness and couldn’t be here. I have to stand up for the people in my district when they ask for my help.” Little Dog was the only official from the Oglala Sioux Tribe on hand. It was not possible to reach President Theresa Two Bulls as of this writing. The Tribal Security Guards said she went to a pow-wow (social event) in Nebraska. A few people present said they heard President Two Bulls on KILI Radio the previous day, asking people to go to Wounded Knee to hear the presentation, but not much information was provided other than that there would be members of the 7th Calvary and National Guardsmen arriving in military air transport. “It is the 7th Calvary that killed our unarmed relatives, why do they need to hear the story? They enacted the story!” said an unidentified elder to the crowd. “Because, Leksi, (Uncle), these people who did this are all CIA, Colonized Indian A****, they are not Lakota!” responded a young mother, carrying her baby on her hip and holding a little girl by the hand. There was a lot of laughter at that point.

Gerald One Feather, an elder and former Tribal President, offered a prayer, and thanked the people for honoring him by asking him to pray. Folks present talked about the need to enforce respect for ancestors buried in the Mass Grave of the 1890 Wounded Knee Massacre.

Note: this occurred on May 1, 2010 at Wounded Knee. It is recorded on videotape.

PHOTOS: Photo of lone person is a Lakota man running toward the helicopters.
Group photo are some of the people in the crowd who came to Wounded Knee to help the elders who didn’t want the military at the Mass Grave.
Other photo is of the three helicopters.

(PASSED, Monday, May 3, 2010)Whereas, Lakota Chief Big Foot and his band were ill, hungry, and running for their lives when they were captured by the United States 7th Calvary and forced to make camp near Wounded Knee Creek. Chief Big Foot carried a White Flag, an International Symbol of Truce, Ceasefire, and Request for Negotiation during times of War. Chief Big Foot and his band were surrounded, unarmed, and massacred by the US 7th Calvary, which included the use of 4 Hotchkiss guns, on December 29, 1890 at Wounded Knee Creek and in the nearby ravines as they ran, seeking to protect their children. The unarmed Lakota men fought the 7th Calvary with sticks and in hand to hand combat. The unarmed Lakota women fought the 7th Calvary with spoons and in hand to hand combat. They fought to their death and deserve to be honored and respected. The frozen bodies of the massacred Lakota were dumped on top of each other and buried in a mass grave. The US government violated the 1868 Ft Laramie Treaty when they broke the Peace of the Treaty and massacred Chief Big Foot, and more than 300 unarmed men, women, and children.
Whereas, the US Medal of Honor is the highest award for valor in action against an enemy force which can be bestowed upon an individual serving in the Armed Services of the United States. Twenty Congressional Medals of Honor were awarded to the 7th Calvary for their roles in killing Lakota unarmed prisoners of war at the 1890 Wounded Knee Massacre, and the US has refused to reclaim those Medals of Honor, and took 100 years, until 1990, for the US to change the word “Battle” to that of “Massacre” at Wounded Knee, and the US refuses to return items taken from the dead bodies, the camp site, and the massacre site.
Whereas, the United States Government has never apologized to the descendants of Chief Big Foot and his band for this atrocity committed against unarmed Prisoners of War, nor has the US ever taken responsible for their act of massacre as a violation of the 1868 Ft Laramie Treaty nor its continued violations of the 1868 Ft Laramie Treaty, nor were the Oglala Lakota people consulted to determine if bringing in the US Military would be received as conducive to heal the trauma caused by the Wounded Knee Massacre of 1890.
Whereas, all Lakota People have great respect Chief Big Foot and his people and for the tragedy that was enacted upon them in one of the world’s most shameful acts ever committed and believe that their Memory must be honored and treated with the utmost respect, including the place where they lie buried in the Wounded Knee Mass Grave.
Whereas, the United States Military arrived at the Wounded Knee Mass Grave on May 1, 2010 in three Military Transport Helicopters that held 40 and more members of the Armed Services of the US without the free, prior, informed consent of the Oglala Lakota people and thus were prevented from landing.
Therefore, Be It Resolved, that the Oglala Sioux Tribe will take every action to see that the United States Reclaims the Twenty Medals of Honor from the 7th Calvary for their role in the Massacre at Wounded Knee, to remove any recognition the US Military bestows to its entities for the Massacre at Wounded Knee, and to obtain the return of personal items taken from Lakota people at the 1890 Massacre.
Therefore Be It Further Resolved, that the Oglala Sioux Tribe, its members, any entity, organization, or resident on the Pine Ridge Reservation will not allow the United States Military from this time forward to come anywhere near the 1890 Wounded Knee Massacre Mass Grave in order to demonstrate Honor and Respect for the Lakota people buried there, and to ensure a peaceful, nonviolent, weapon-free zone for the Mass Gravesite area.


Debra White Plume said...

Greetings All: This Resolution is being presented today to the Tribal Council. We will see if they pass it or not. There is unfinished business about the Massacre at Wounded Knee. Maybe the Tribal Council will stand with us.

Unknown said...

I love it! Please ask me my opinion on this matter, I was there and saw everything from a totally different way...My ancestors are also buried there, my lineage comes from the Big Foot band. I do not follow such a "radical" road as this Lakota group does. They say they represent ALL the 7th generation, ALL the Grass Roots people- what do I have to do to qualify? I teach my children to learn the ways of the non-native and to not look at color or race but the person, is that so bad? Not ALL people are against this or that...Heal ourselves, move forward... What are they doing to the future of our Lakota children? I do not do illegal drugs nor do I drink alcoholic beverages. I am looked at funny by my own people because I do not participate "radically". I was asked to leave the gravesite several times by a Lakota from WK district because that is "thier" gravesite. Then, asked to buy a handmade item for $5...makes me wonder what goes through thier minds and why this site is "thiers". I was there ask me...I'll tell you my view. This resolution was passed as a "shirt tail" to another resolution. The medals of honor would be revoked by some miracle, because according to the Dept of Defense - "there was never a war declared" grandmother went to Washington DC to fight for this issue many years ago, many times...Please ask me what I think. I too am part of the 7th generation, I too am a decendent, I too am Lakota, I also have a family to provide for, I also have my future and the future of my children to see and protect. Ask me, ask my perspective. Thank You.

Anonymous said...

We all have had alot to say.
Finaly, regardless of Nation, Traditional God fearing Natives are my family, and my WHOLE heart is with them.

Nathan Empsall said...

Any word on whether or not the resolution passed?

tsongbird said...

i think all of this chaos is good because it will make people remember what Wounded Knee is, in case they forgot. But, EVERYONE should really be consulted on whether or not military should or should not land on Wounded Knee. Tribal Council knows that is sacred ground. Allowing U.S. military to land on another Soveriegn nations land requires a little more than "oh ya it's ok". IF it ever was "ok" I think it should be for a very very formal apology and many other important facts to be admitted and addressed by the U.S. government. Yes the 7the calvery should continue to be educated on what they did and that it was wrong, now they have been.

tsongbird said...

i think all of this chaos is good because it will make people remember what Wounded Knee is, in case they forgot. But, EVERYONE should really be consulted on whether or not military should or should not land on Wounded Knee. Tribal Council knows that is sacred ground. Allowing U.S. military to land on another Soveriegn nations land requires a little more than "oh ya it's ok". IF it ever was "ok" I think it should be for a very very formal apology and many other important facts to be admitted and addressed by the U.S. government. Yes the 7the calvery should continue to be educated on what they did and that it was wrong, now they have been.

Anonymous said...

Ghouls Hunter, I absolutely agree with you!!! Let us teach our children to become lawyers, doctors, engineers, teachers, etc. We need to empower ourselves with knowledge not finger pointing and saying "he/she/government did this to me last week or one hundred years ago"!

Anonymous said...

Accepting an apology?

United States apologizes to American Indians – but forgets to tell them?!
Think the U.S. is on your side?

April 28th, 2010

more here:

Senator Sam Brownback, R-KS, has been introducing an apology resolution to
American Indians in the Senate since 2004. It was nothing more than just a
general statement of apology and didn’t create any lawsuit potential nor
offer to pay any form of reparations. Still, it took under December 2009 for
the resolution to pass.

Then, inexplicably, President Barack Obama signed the Native American
Apology Resolution on Dec. 19 as part of a defense appropriations spending
bill WITHOUT telling any Indians or tribal leaders.

“. . . The resolution originated in Congress and had passed the Senate as
stand-alone legislation in the fall. The House ended up adding the
resolution to their version of the defense bill in conference.

Sen. Sam Brownback, R-Kan., originally introduced the measure intending “to
officially apologize for the past ill-conceived policies by the U.S.
government toward the Native peoples of this land and re-affirm our
commitment toward healing our nation’s [sic] wounds and working toward
establishing better relationships rooted in reconciliation.” His bill passed
the Senate in 2008 and 2009.

The version signed by Obama became watered down, not making a direct apology
from the government, but rather apologizing “on behalf of the people of the
United States to all Native peoples for the many instances of violence,
maltreatment, and neglect inflicted on Native peoples by citizens of the
United States.”

The resolution also includes a disclaimer: Nothing in it authorizes or
supports any legal claims against the United States, and the resolution does
not settle any claims.

Even with the more general language, the apology is historic, but the White
House has made no announcements to date about it. Nor has Obama expressed an
apology to any tribes or Indian citizens, despite saying on the presidential
campaign trail that he thought an apology was warranted.”

” . . . The resolution Obama signed specifically “urges the President to
acknowledge the wrongs of the United States against Indian tribes in the
history of the United States in order to bring healing to this land.

So, by signing the document as part of the defense spending bill, did Obama
fulfill the resolution? Or, does he have an obligation to say the apology
out loud and to let tribes know he signed the resolution? . . . .”

An apology won't change anything it is in definition "In part, Brownback’s resolution reads: “The United States, acting through Congress -- apologizes on behalf of the people of the United States to all Native Peoples for the many instances of violence, maltreatment, and neglect inflicted on Native Peoples by citizens of the United States; and expresses its regret for the ramifications of former wrongs and its commitment to build on the positive relationships of the past and present to move toward a brighter future where all the people of this land live reconciled as brothers and sisters, and harmoniously steward and protect this land together.”
The resolution, which failed to pass in the previous Congress, does not authorize the settlement of any outstanding claims made against the United States and as Brownback points out, “does not resolve many challenges still facing Native peoples.”