![]() |
| Photo courtesy Becket Law |
May 10, 2025
Federal court halts destruction of Oak Flat
May 3, 2024
San Carlos Apache Tribe Petitions U.N. to Protect Sacred Oak Flat from Copper Mine
SAN CARLOS APACHE — The San Carlos Apache Tribe has petitioned the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (UNCERD) to call upon the United States government to withhold the transfer of sacred Oak Flat for the proposed Resolution Copper Mine in Arizona.
The Tribe’s 15-page petition details the “imminent” threat to “Apache religion, culture, and spiritual well-being” from the proposed mine that would destroy Oak Flat, which is listed on the National Register of Historic Places as a Traditional Cultural Property. Oak Flat is known in Apache as Chí’chil Biłdagoteel, which means “a broad flat of Emory oak trees.”
June 24, 2022
Divided Ninth Circuit Appeals Court leads Apache Stronghold to Supreme Court
By Apache Stronghold
https://chrisp.lautre.net/wpblog/?p=7179
SAN CARLOS, Arizona – Today, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, in a 2-1 decision ruled that the request for a preliminary injunction to halt the land exchange of Oak Flat be denied. Apache Stronghold—a coalition of Apaches, other Native peoples, and non-Native allies, which is represented by the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty—has vowed to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court immediately.
The Preliminary Injunction would have stopped Resolution Copper, a foreign owned mining company, from gaining control over Oak Flat through a land exchange, until the court case, Apache Stronghold vs. the U.S. was decided. The court ruled that Apache Stronghold's case against the United States had no likelihood of winning.
December 13, 2019
'Apaches Standing Strong to Defend Sacred Oak Flat from Mining' by Sandra Rambler
| Photo by Sandra Rambler, San Carlos Apache |
'Apaches Standing Strong to Defend Sacred Oak Flat from Mining' by Sandra Rambler
Chi’Chil’Bilda’Goteel (Oak Flat) -- How do you respond to a White Man whose name is Paul Gosar, an Arizona Congressman who recently said, “You’re still wards of the government.”
And then he continues and says, “One of the federal government’s dirty little secrets is that Native American tribes are not fully sovereign nations in today’s society.”
December 27, 2015
Chasing McCain Away: Brazen Acts of Native Americans in 2015
![]() |
| Chasing McCain off Navajo Nation |
By Brenda Norrell
Censored News
copyright
French translation by Christine Prat
http://www.chrisp.lautre.net/wpblog/?p=3144
| Apaches protesting Sen. McCain's copper mine on sacred Oak Flat |
Censored News pick for the most brazen act of 2015: Navajos Chasing Arizona Sen. John McCain off the Navajo Nation. Fabulously called "Sneaky Snake McCain," by San Carlos Apaches fighting McCain's new copper mine with McCain's best buddies at Resolution Copper, McCain's status as a bottom feeder is absolute.
The fact that McCain is still on the US Senate Committee for Indian Affairs reveals that the Committee was set up to steal Indian land and water rights, and dupe everyone else into believing that the US system works.
Meanwhile, US Homeland Security gave the southern border security contract to Israel's defense contractor Elbit Systems, manufacturer of drones and Apartheid systems surrounding Palestine.
Now, Elbit is on the southern border of Arizona and pushing its new spy towers on Tohono O'odham land in traditional O'odham communities.
The District of Gu-Vo has said, "No!" to these spy towers which target traditional O'odham burial grounds.
However, Tohono O'odham human rights activists point out that the tribal government was long ago co-opted by the US government and is powerless to protect the Tohono O'odham people from the onslaught of the oppression of the US government and its new partner Israel.
The Bottom Line: Peabody Coal on Black Mesa
| Louise Benally Photo Christine Prat |
Louise Benally of Big Mountain, testifying before the Bureau of Land Management about coal mining in Farmington, N.M, said it best this year.
Although the regional media has been bought and sold with Peabody Coal's dollars and the surrounding parasitic political influence, Louise Benally describes the 40-year-resistance to coal mining, relocation and McCain, in her testimony to the BLM:
In my community of Black Mesa in 1974 there was a Congressional legislation known as Public Law 93531 that was passed to remove 10,000 Navajos, 300 Hopis to make way for Peabody coal company.
As of today BLM is the major owner of Navajo Generating Station, and if we're going to talk about climate change justice for all, let's shut Navajo Generating Station down! Because it is allowed to continue to pollute and to kill people. This is ongoing as of today.
I want that you as the people of the Department of the Interior do your activities and call the Hopi government to stop impounding people's animals. The sheep, the goats, the horses, the cattle is what we live off of. That's our food. That's our economy. That's all we have.
We don't have electricity. We don't have running water.

Yet the power that is pumped out of Black Mesa goes down to where John McCain is laid out in the sun with his shades on, and he needs to stop stealing our water.
The Colorado River, he's after again, after we told him so many times no.
The utility companies, they eat the earth up here, suck out her breath out, so they can get electricity and, you know, we are left with nothing. Period. Nothing. Except ourselves and what we have. But yet these coal companies are polluting our air, killing our environment, killing our people through actions of flawed policies. This needs to stop. We're sick and tired of your greed!
Throughout the continent, the Arctic drilling needs to stop. The pipeline for the oils in the Midwest need to stop that's coming out of Alberta. You're sending all that to other countries. India and China needs to be taught how to convert to renewable energies that don't pollute. That's the only hope we have.
Now, do your job. Make that change.
US Border Patrol: An Occupying Army
On the issues of the occupying Army of the US Border Patrol on Tohono O'odham land, and what this means for sovereignty, Mike Wilson, Tohono O'odham, and Mark Maracle, Mohawk Warrior, said it best.
"The Tohono O'odham tribal government has completely surrendered to the US Homeland Security,” Wilson said in the live broadcast of the AIM West Conference in November.
In response, Mohawk Warrior Mark Maracle said that Mohawks do not wait for anyone to tell them that they are sovereign. "You don't have sovereignty unless you assert sovereignty,” Maracle told Censored News.
Indianz is owned by the wealthy Ho-Chunk Inc. of Nebraska. Ho-Chunk Inc. also received a contract from the US government for domestic and international spying, with an office at the Pentagon.
Perhaps publishers and editors are afraid that the real issues might be laid bare -- including the fact that Sen. McCain's goal has been to rob Native people -- while riding in their parades as a faux hero.
Perhaps it is hard to keep real reporters quiet about the three coal-fired power plants on the Navajo Nation and the fact that they are leading dirty coal polluters in the world.
Perhaps real reporters would point out the Raytheon Missile factory on the Navajo commercial farm, NAPI, and question if years of planting with Monsanto seeds on NAPI has resulted in the mutation of traditional local crops.
Casino funded national news has resulted in a new era of plagiarism, fraud and short cuts.
MacDonald planned to press for the Winter's Doctrine water rights for Navajos in federal court, ensuring Navajos would have their rights to expansive water rights needed for future generations.
| Sen. Gosar called cops on Apache grandmothers |
When San Carlos Apache led a delegation to Washington to fight the bill, and defend sacred Oak Flat, Apache grandmothers went calling on Rep. Paul Gosar in his Congressional office in Washington.
Gosar called the cops on them.
When it comes to defending Oak Flat, Apache youth Naelyn Pike, 16, granddaughter of Wendsler Nosie, rose to the forefront. Listen to her words on this video, at Oak Flat, by Christine Prat:
The bottom line is the slow and toxic genocide in Indian country, carried out by the US government, corrupt tribal officials, Congressmen, non-Indian attorneys, and the big players in the red light district: The media who can be bought and sold.
Now you know the rest of the story.
Navajos Chase McCain off Navajo Nation
http://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2015/08/dine-protesters-chase-john-mccain-off.html
Israel's Elbit targets Tohono O'odham with spy towers
http://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2015/09/us-israeli-pact-targets-traditional.html
Tohono O'odham and Mohawk on US Border Patrol and Sovereignty
http://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2015/11/mohawk-and-tohono-oodham-sovereignty.html
The Rest of the Story: Peter MacDonald: How lies under oath sent MacDonald to prison, and Navajo Winter's Doctrine water rights were lost, with letter from MacDonald to Censored News on water rights:
http://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2015/11/us-theft-of-water-rights-and.html
Gosar calls cops on Apache grandmothers
http://bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2015/07/ariz-rep-gosar-calls-cops-on-apache.html
Brenda Norrell has been a news reporter in Indian country for 33 years. She began as a reporter for Navajo Times, during the 18 years that she lived on the Navajo Nation. She was a stringer for AP and USA Today during those years, covering the Navajo Nation and federal courts. After serving as a longtime staff reporter for Indian Country Today in the Southwest, she was censored, then terminated in 2006. Because of this, she created Censored News, with no advertising, grants or revenues, to expose what Indian Country Today was censoring. Since 2006, she has traveled with the Zapatistas through Mexico, and provided live coverage of events throughout the west, and the Mother Earth Conference in Bolivia, without pay.
Censored News depends on readers to survive, please share our links!
http://www.bsnorrell.blogspot.com/2015/12/chasing-mccain-away-brazen-acts-of.html
For permission to repost this article, contact brendanorrell@gmail.com
September 19, 2015
Apache invite Europeans for global resistance gathering at Oak Flat March 2016
![]() |
| Oak Flat photo Brenda Norrell |
Censored News Exclusive
English and Dutch
Dutch translation by Alice Holemans, NAIS at:
http://www.denaisgazet.be/nieuws/natives-reageren-hillary-clinton-probeert-stemmen-te-ronselen-met-kxl
Chi'Chil'Bilda'Goteel (Oak Flat) -- Apache Wendsler Nosie invited European supporters to come to Oak Flat in mid-March and join forces in this global resistance that is not only protecting Oak Flat from Resolution Copper, but is becoming the catalyst to unify Native people against the aggression of corporate oppressors who seek to destroy their lands around the world.
Standing in the heart of the resistance camp here, Nosie sent a special invitation to supporters in Europe to gather here in mid-March 2016.
Nosie also sent a message of solidarity to Mauna Kea in Hawaii where Native people are resisting telescope construction on their sacred mountain. Nosie himself was arrested and jailed here in Arizona, by the University of Arizona, as he prayed on Mount Graham during the long years of resistance to protect Mount Graham from massive telescope construction.
A special invitation is being extended to Bolivia President Evo Morales to come to the global resistance gathering here in March of 2016.
![]() |
| Lillian Bread and Tina Anderson, San Carlos Apache, occupying sacred Oak Flat on Thursday. Photo Brenda Norrell |
"This is my way of being as an Apache girl," she said, standing on this sacred ground.
She described seeing the trees, and the acorns fall off, along with going to the springs and petroglyphs.
Although many of the mainstream society speak of Indians as if they are a thing of the past, she said, "We are still here, we are still breathing, the blood goes through our veins."
Speaking on becoming a woman, she said to be a woman is to bear children and this is the connection of women to Mother Earth.
Referring to birthing and renewing, she said, "That is what Mother Earth does. This is our direct connection to her."
She said Apache girls have their ceremony here when they are transforming into a woman.
"That is who I am. As people we came from our Mother."
Surrounded by the memories of her childhood and ceremonies here, she said, "This is who we are."
"All things are sacred," she said, and added, "Man's greed brings destruction."
Naelyn said Resolution Copper is owned by Rio Tinto, an Australian corporation.
"They want to destroy this place for mining."
"They want to come here and destroy this for mining. If that happens, I can't come here."
She said if this happens, if this sacred land is destroyed for copper mining, then she will not be able to bring her own children here someday, to pick the acorns and pick the berries.
"There are so many things that the United States has done to our people."
"My ancestors fought for me to live. That is why we have people here to occupy."
Naelyn points out the unifying force that the struggle at Oak Flat has brought.
"Many tribes are unifying. The resistance is here. We are going to show the truth."
Naelyn also points out a fact that the Zapatistas in the south have said from the beginning: "Enough is Enough!"
Naelyn said, "We are tired and done with being discriminated against."
She said the Apache young people come here in order to know who they are. The girls becoming women come here for ceremonies.
There are sweats for the young boys to learn their songs.
Reflecting her grandfather Wendlser's words, that this struggle is not just about Oak Flat, she adds, "There are so many places in this world we are fighting for."
"Corporations think this is theirs, it is not, it is Mother Earth's."
People are coming here from throughout the world, she said, and they see the future is hope.
"My children will come here -- if we are willing to fight."
She said Mother Earth can renew herself, regardless of what people do.
Of Resolution Copper, she said their intent is genocide.
"They have tried to destroy my people."
"I see all of us coming together."
She told Resolution Copper, "Leave or we will keep fighting! Tribes are unifying to fight!"
"We are going to keep this place sacred."
Referring to the United States long war of genocide targeting Apaches, she said, "The United States tried to strip our identity away."
She said the United States' attempt to destroy the Apache failed.
She recalled how her ancestors fought for her survival.
"I still wear my camp dress. I still wear my moccasins. I am Apache. We are coming together. I am going to fight for what is right."
"If we don't keep fighting for who we are, we are nothing."
She said one thing this struggle has shown her is how strong her people are.
"We are a family. We are going to fight and we are going to keep this place sacred."
![]() |
| Naelyn Pike, New York, Photo by Sun Fox |
He shared Naelyn's words of how when she shot an arrow into the sky, she prayed that it would become as stars and this message would be carried to the whole world.
Seated nearby are Lillian Bread and Tina Anderson, San Carlos Apache grandmothers who are here occupying, being present to protect this sacred land.
Tina Anderson was recently in Washington with the grassroots delegation seeking repeal of the Resolution Copper land exchange that Sen. John McCain and other Arizona Congressmen sneaked through in the defense bill.
Anderson recalls visiting Arizona Rep. Paul Gosar and the events that led up to the now-famous headline: "Gosar calls cops on Apache Grandmothers."
When Apache grandmothers went to speak with Rep. Gosar in his Congressional office, he pretended not to be there. However, it turns out that Gosar was hiding in an another room, which became a known fact after other visitors left the office and told Apaches, "He's in there."
![]() |
| Photo by Apache Stronghold |
"Well, that's a stupid thing for a politician to do," I add.
Nosie's invitation to Europeans comes as Christine and Theo Prat of France were interviewing Nosie and Naelyn at Oak Flat. Christine is also the French translator for Censored News.
Meanwhile, the Mohawks continue to be in the forefront of resistance.
When the cellphone rings on our way to the border from Oak Flat, it is Mark Maracle, Mohawk. Speaking on the defense of the land, and the no-compromise position of the Mohawks in the north, Maracle said the struggle is the same for Native people everywhere.
"What they need to realize is that all of this land is their land."
brendanorrell@gmail.com
copyright Brenda Norrell
.
![]() |
| James Ybarra at Oak Flat camp Photo Brenda Norrell |
April 21, 2015
Apaches Photo 'Sneaky Snake McCain'
December 5, 2014
Sen. McCain leads planned theft of Apache sacred lands for copper mining
McCain is the darling of the coyotes and snakes

By Brenda Norrell
Censored News
Sen. John McCain's new mode of genocide is no where more obvious than in the slick theft of Apache sacred lands for the benefit of a foreign corporation for copper mining. Of course, McCain's theft of sacred lands in Arizona is nothing new, nor is the complicity by the corrupt media who are in the saddle with fellow politicians and corporate bedfellows.
![]() |
| Apache elders protest Resolution Copper |
With deception and spin, McCain and his team of thieves hid away the theft of Oak Flat, sacred lands of Apache, in the National Defense Authorization Act passed by the Senate on Friday, after being passed by the House. McCain and his fellow thieves in Congress have duped the public once again. And they all came out smiling.
The snakes used similar spin and deception for the so-called Navajo Hopi land dispute, which was actually to clear Navajos off their land at Black Mesa for Peabody Coal. The coal fuels one of the world's dirtiest coal-fired power plants, Navajo Generating Station, on the Navajo Nation in Arizona.
The stench of this government and media deception is also found in the secret files of the United States internment camps where Aleuts were forced to live, and many died of starvation and disease, during World War II. Even in the mid-Twentieth Century, the US government carried out a secret program of sterilizing American Indian women in Indian Health Service hospitals.
The deceptions are also obvious in the United States destabilization of Mexico by providing assault weapons to the drug cartels. The ATF's gunrunning, including Project Gunrunner, Fast and Furious and Operation Wide Receiver, began under the Bush administration in Texas in 2005, according a US Justice Dept. document.
Around the world, the US military's agenda is to provide weapons and whatever is needed for guerrillas, regardless of whether they are on the side of good or not. This fact is made clear in the US Army manuals. The purpose is to destabilize countries from within, which gives the US the advantage and enriches the US corporate war profiteers. It also creates homelessness for the dispossessed, who become migrants, and can once again be turned into profit by private prisons in the US.
Perhaps America is too busy shopping at Walmart -- which has made slaves of their employees while the owners became billionaires -- to care about the Obama administration killing innocent women and children with drones, as they strike without individuals being charged or given trials.
Perhaps Americans are too busy doing their holiday shopping to care that Indigenous Peoples defending their lands around the world have been assassinated in 2014 by mining companies and others.
Perhaps Americans are all satisfied with the watered-down US torture reports, media cover-ups of police murders of blacks, and dull TV news and national radio programs claiming there is no racism in America.
Perhaps one of the saddest of all of the news items in 2014 was the lack of it. As national reporters for Indian country news continued to stay home and plagiarize, they let the coyotes and snakes run free in Congress.
McCain, once again, is the darling of the coyotes and snakes.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Congress gives Native American lands to foreign mining company with new NDAA












